It sounds like a couple of judges from the state Appellate Division in Manhattan didn’t like the arguments put forth by Michael Corbett regarding activities surrounding the estate of William Gottlieb. The Post article doesn’t indicate a timetable for a formal ruling. We haven’t been able to find additional accounts of the hearing as of yet. Will keep looking.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court dismissed years of juvenile convictions issued by former Luzerne County Judge Mark Ciavarella. Read the story here. This doesn’t have an estate angle, but it certainly shows how systemic abuse of power can take place in our courts – a charge made by many Involuntary Redistribution of Assets (IRA) targets.
And speaking of IRA, Pat takes to task our terminology:
Redistribution of Assets is not exactly the right term used in this web site; it should be withdrawal of assets, smuggling of assets, and disguising of assets – since that is what occurs in Estate of Denial cases.
If the IRS were to take their obligations seriously, the beneficiaries would be less likely to be targets of thieves, and scoundrels since the IRS stands in the same shoes with the beneficiaries, usually. When one loses, both lose. Of course, beneficiaries can lose twice – once by being raped by the denial, and once perhaps by the IRS, so privity is not so remote as to be negligible in these cases.
Opinions are always welcome. The “Involuntary” term is a critical part of the phrase. With no time today for a long philosophy regarding asset redistribution, suffice to say that any reform in this area will first require estate abuse and probate corruption to be recognized as legitimate public policy issues. As America is currently experiencing an aggressive state-sponsored redistribution (or confiscation) of assets and other wealth through government channels, it seems timely and potentially effective to position IRA as a companion issue quietly occurring on a more individual basis to increasing numbers of Americans.
Estate of Denial® provides news, analysis and commentary on abusive practices occurring in probate courts and via probate instruments (wills, trusts, guardianships, powers of attorney). We provide original perspective to educate the public regarding this growing threat to both individual freedoms and property rights.

